My first love was Chucky, and I'm trying to remember if I dated anyone before him. I think I dated Trevor for like a minute and Tim for a very short time. That was in early high school. Chucky and I met in middle school, but we started dating during my sophomore or junior year—I’m not sure which. I got to know him on a bus trip with the marching band, but romantic feelings didn't take over until we were in the middle of a car crash after a Sandi Patty Messiah concert.
There was a lot that Chucky taught me. Most of it was probably not good, but he did teach me that people are who they say they are. He showed me that fighting for someone's attention isn’t worth it and that compromising to get what I want in a relationship doesn’t end well.
One thing about Chucky was that he didn’t require me to be anybody else, and he didn’t expect me to play dumb. Chucky valued my intelligence.
A lot of high school guys were put off by my intelligence. They felt like I was insulting them by using words they didn’t understand. But Chucky never felt like I was talking down to him. He was proud to have a smart girlfriend—and that was important to me. Our conflict came from the fact that he wanted to have sex, and I didn’t. So, he would drop me anytime he thought he had a chance with another girl, especially if he thought he could get sex from her. Then, inevitably, we’d get back together because that’s how those kinds of relationships go. I learned from him that a person who won’t say they love me, really doesn’t love me—even if I feel loved by them. He taught me what conditional love has to offer.
I know it’s not okay, but I feel like I still do that—I still accept less because I don’t expect more. It was kind of fair, though. I wanted love from that relationship, and he wasn’t willing to give that. He wanted sex from that relationship, and I wasn’t willing to give that. If we had been mature adults, we might have recognized that we wanted different things and should’ve just let it go.
Chucky and I navigated that teenage stuff together. I’m incredibly grateful to have had someone who was gentle and fun to go through all of that nonsense with. I don’t know if it would have been any better any other way.
I don’t know what I would have learned if I had found somebody who genuinely loved me and was willing to say so. You’re not in love in high school. You just aren’t. So the fact that he wouldn’t say that he was—maybe that’s good. I don’t know.
He certainly didn’t do anything to curb my fear of abandonment. He would just abandon me if he thought he could get laid with someone else. But he did teach me that it’s important to have fun. Chucky lives for fun—that’s his thing. So what life lesson did my first love teach me? There’s no value in compromise.
I feel like he taught me that if I accept trade-offs, I will get trade-offs.